Masters of Sex Review

I normally don’t read reviews of a show before I watch it.

I’ve tried it before and I found myself looking for reasons to agree with the reviewer.  If the reviewer had nothing but sneers, I wanted to sneer along.  If the reviewer loved it, I kept looking for the gold.

I read Flavorwire‘s review of Masters of Sex before I ever watched it, and I actually found myself looking for reasons to disagree with their distaste for this show.  I guess I felt bad for it.  When I first heard the concept, I desperately wanted the show to be good, to be (as Flavorwire perfectly put it) Mad Men from Peggy’s perspective.

No such luck.

This show leaves nothing to like.  The show’s namesake is a flat, dry man who seems to hate everything and everyone he comes across–his lack of charisma is possibly supposed to be humorous or humanizing, but it just feels like more jerk behavior.  The heroine, Virginia Johnson (played by a continually wide-eyed and tight-lipped Lizzy Caplan) seems so determined to be a part of the sex study (for reasons unclear) that she seems to be willfully ignorant of Masters’ awfulness. As for the other characters?  They’re either flat or woefully under-explored.

And the plotlines.  Will the study be at the hospital or won’t it (does it matter?)  Masters is (gasp) a lying asshole who treats his wife for fertility problems she doesn’t have, just to put off having a baby.  Virginia is some sort of magical sex nymph that beguiles all men she comes across.  We’re to believe that Masters is obsessed with her, as evidenced by the fact that he asks her to be a part of the study with him (ya know, do it.)   So very dull, so very flat.  Even the style of the show doesn’t feel complete the way Mad Men does.

Michael Sheen and Lizzy Caplan are so much better than this.  They can act the part they need to be acting; he can be dry but lovable, she could handle being grounded, determined, adaptable and fierce.

I don’t get the sense that Masters or Johnson are discovering anything.  The research itself feels like an aside, a necessary device to allow the writers to create unrelated contrived events.  Even when people are naked onscreen and miming sex acts, nothing feels risque or particularly exciting for the viewer.  I get that it’s not really supposed to titillate, but what these people are doing is revolutionary for the time period; there should be some feeling created for the viewer that what’s happening is new, exciting and thrilling.  Instead, you’re just mourning what could’ve been.

3 thoughts on “Masters of Sex Review

  1. My husband and I have been watching the show and I don’t see Masters as a jerk, he seems like a bit of an Aspie actually. My husband is an Aspie and he has often been misunderstood as being abrupt or rude or cold by people that don’t know him very well, genius without social skills is common in Aspies.
    I have never followed Mad Men so I am watching the show without comparing it to anything else but I like it.

    1. Part of my “desperate to want to like this show” was comparing aspects of his behavior to an Aspie, and I can definitely see that (I feel like there’s a microtrend of Aspies on TV of late, no?)
      In the book, Virginia says that each of them were the most secretive people on the planet. Given that, I’m trying to decide if my disconnect from these characters is just that–the people behind the characters dammed themselves up so completely that they didn’t connect to anyone, including one another.

      I mostly compare it to Mad Men because I can FEEL the period in every moment. Most lines of dialogue in Mad Men are designed to really frame the time period and often to reflect how different things are now. It happens in Masters of Sex, but I feel like they need to lay just a bit more groundwork to show just how backwards the sex research of the time was, and the general attitude toward sex. You get that in bits and piece, but I think it needs to be really obvious at times.

      1. We are thrilled to see more Aspies showing up on TV. My husband has only recently been exploring his Aspieness (is that a word?), so seeing more people like him on TV is very exciting and interesting.
        As for The Masters Of Sex, some shows need time to click and come together, for now we will keep watching.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s